To Banish or Not to Banish?

While Cole was banished to a remote Alaskan island as a consequence for his actions, banishment is not widely used in Canada, and it appears that banishment has never been used as a consequence for a young Canadian who has committed a crime. Think back to your earlier classroom discussions on banishment, and consider the events of Touching Spirit Bear.

Then answer the following questions about the use of banishment:

1. What types of location would be suitable in Canada for banishment? What are the benefits and drawbacks of the locations which you have chosen?
2. Why do you think there has yet to be an instance of a young Canadian being banished?
3. Overall, do you think banishment for youth is a good idea? Why or why not?

Answer each question in a short paragraph (three total) and this time include an appropriate image.

One More Chance

In Chapter One, Cole mockingly thinks to himself, "Whatever happened, he could always count on having one more last chance." Every time Cole broke the law or hurt someone, he was told, "This is your last chance." Even Garvey advises Cole, "Don't waste this chance" when he leaves him on the island the first time. Now, after everything he has done, Cole is given yet another "last chance"; the Circle has decided to return him to the island to complete his banishment.

In your opinion, does Cole deserve another chance or should he be sent to jail as Peter's lawyer suggests? Support your opinion with evidence from the novel.

Things you might want to consider:
Who is responsible for Cole's behavious?
How has Cole changed since his first stay on the island?
How is he still the same?
How have the "banishment" rules and funding changed? Is this enough?
What message does this "chance" send to Cole? Peter? Other young offenders?

Thanks to Ms. Sibs for this entry.